Silent reading is not only reading with your lips closed, it's also understanding what you have read. It's a term students need to know and a behavior they should learn.
So, at the appropriate time in the school year, to help the kiddos understand it, we practice reading silently.
As you might imagine, some students have a hard time learning how to do this! And there can be several reasons why.
ONE REASON is …
In the beginning, it’s simply a problem for them to read with their lips closed.
Once again, today, I explained to my class what “silent reading” is …
Amy nodded, indicating she understood. “Teacher, you know what else? You can TALK silently, too.”
Her face brightened as she told me about her revelation ... “And, guess what! Nobody can hear you, but ‘cept God!”
During the silent reading test today, I noticed Amy looking around the classroom everywhere... everywhere except at her test.
So I whispered, “Amy, are you reading?”
She nodded enthusiastically and reassured me. "I’m reading... but 'cept my mouth's not lippin’ it.”
Often a first grader will ask, “What’s this word?”
I usually answer in one of two ways … If it’s a SIGHT WORD, I simply give them the answer. But if the word can be pronounced phonetically, I always say, “Let me help you sound it out."
Today, Weesie was prepared for my standard response …
“Teacher, what’s this word? And I already SOUNDED it out and SOUNDED it out!” Her shoulders slumped in total defeat. “But I NEVER EVER COULD spit it out.”
Later, Ben asked me what a word was …
“And, I already sounded it out,” he said, dryly.
I believed he knew the word, so I teased him. “Isn’t that word right there on the tip of your tongue?”
“It might be,” he grumbled, miserably, “but I done pushed and pushed, and it WILL NOT come out!”
Because of the rain the first graders have been inside for the past two weeks. Naturally, they have grown restless! So today, there was way too much classroom noise during reading.
Even though the blue reading group was seated at the reading table right with me, with the rain and all, I was unable to hear the kiddos read.
The other students – at their desks – were supposed to be reading silently.
But since silent reading is a skill most of them haven’t yet mastered, what they do is whisper read… Something they create naturally on their own.
WHO WAS THAT making all of that noise?
As my eyes scanned the classroom, I discovered the sources. There were two of them.
Tommy and Joe Joe were practically yelling as they read.
I went and whispered first to Tommy. “Please, you must read quietly, so I can hear the blue group read to me."
He glared at me.
"Just read the way your mother does,” I said, encouraging him. “Mouth closed.”
Frowning, he looked at me as if I were looney.
“My momma don’t read with her mouth closed. She reads loud. LOUDER THAN MY OL' MAN.”
Suddenly, Joe Joe stood and stomped his foot. “Sh-h! I wish all you young-uns would SHUT UP! I'm trying to read!”
“Sh-hhhhh…” I pointed to his seat. “Sit. Read. Lips closed.”
“What you SPECK from me, Teacher?" He was thoroughly disgusted. "You KNOW I can’t hear what I’m saying, ‘less I LIP IT!”
* * *
Yep, learning to read silently can be really difficult for the firsties ... But I must say that whenever they're practicing it, they are SOOO CUTE!